Few other concepts whip up more emotional reactions or rouse more confusion than the “fear of the Lord”. This phrase occurs throughout the Bible, but nowhere is there a definition or clear explanation of what it entails. This leaves “fear of the Lord” open to tremendously diverse interpretations depending on one’s’ foundational perspective of the nature of God. Those of us tending towards seeing God as a punitive and wrathful deity define this fear as terror (which is, in fact, its common day meaning). Those tending towards a view of God as a loving and compassionate entity stretch the word beyond its common day meaning to refer to intense reverence or awe.
As to my own bias, my appreciation of fearing God transformed over the years. Early on I held to a rather temperamental, wrathful paradigm of God. I figured He got frustrated with me often in my repeated failures and, while I knew on some level of His universal love, I figured His disappointment and even disgust towards me was a fairly routine response interrupted with forgiveness and comfort. Sometimes that forgiveness had to be a begrudging thing for God, or so I thought. As I grew in my understanding and my faith matured, this changed slowly. However, I still figured “fearing” God meant being afraid of His reactions to me and so I persisted in needing to walk softly, sin little, be penitent when I slipped, and do many things to engender God’s favor towards me.
On good days, I read a sufficient amount of the Bible, worked on memorizing whole passages of the Holy Text, prayed and meditated for a long time, and served regularly. On these days, I experienced God smiling upon me. On other days, I just kept asking for His forgiveness and hoped my time of penitence would be short and hoped that I had not lost God’s favor or forfeited His gifts to me.
I want to make it clear, because words matter, that my experience of God often jives poorly with the reality of Him. God, in His grace, transformed my apprehension of Him in the last years. But, let me save that for a moment.
The Hebrew word often used which is translated to “fear” is yare’ and the definition for it does include both the ordinary sense of terror or fright as well as a sense of awe and reverence. So, looking at the exact historical text does not resolve this issue. When that is the case, we must look at examples and context. I believe the story of Jonah sheds light on what is meant when the Bible speaks of fearing God or “fear of the Lord”.
Jonah, a prophet of God, was called upon to go the people of Ninevah and proclaim His word to repent. For generations, the Ninevites tormented Israel. Jonah had no love of them and, frankly, disagreed sharply with God’s desire to give them another chance. Rather, Jonah would have only welcomed a call to destruction of Ninevah – not a second chance. So, Jonah ran the other way and even boarded a ship to go as far as possible from God’s call on his life.
While on the ship, God whipped up a big storm that threatened to destroy the ship and all upon it. While the sailors scrambled to do all they could to stay afloat, including tossing cargo overboard, Jonah went to the hold of the ship and took a nap. This scene gives us a picture of two ways fear regarding God manifest. By his own account, when confronted by the sailors, Jonah feared God. Yet, he ran in defiance trying to get free of what God wanted of him. Further, when things seemed most dire, he slept. The sailors, after hearing of Jonah’s God whom He correctly said created the land as well as the very sea upon which they sailed, also had some sort of a fear of God. The text is revealing:
Then the men were exceedingly afraid and said to him, “What is this that you have done!” For the men knew that he was fleeing from the presence of the LORD, because he had told them. Jonah 1:10 (ESV)
The Orthodox Hebrew Bible uses the phrase “yirah gedolah” for “exceedingly afraid”. Other versions say “greatly feared” or “extremely frightened”. They witnessed God’s power and were terrified of Him. Jonah tells them they must toss him overboard to escape the storm, but in their fright, they try to row for shore instead. Finally they relent and toss Jonah into the sea and the storm immediately ceases.
The sailor had great terror of God when they heard He was creating the storm that threatened them, and then when the storm ceased, they also had great terror, but it shifted. They had confirmation of what Jonah said and then truly believed what they had heard. Now they feared God, but it was still with a great terror; they continued to be afraid of God:
Then the men feared the LORD exceedingly, and they offered a sacrifice to the LORD and made vows. Jonah 1:16 (ESV)
The English Standard Version of the bible juxtaposes the “extremely afraid” in verse 10 against the phrase “feared . . . exceedingly” of verse 16 to highlight the shift. But, the real difference is that the terror they felt shifted from what they did not know to what they did know. The nature of the fear remained the same. It can be argued that these sailors were converted or, as we would say it now in many churches – saved, because the next verse show them making vows to God and offering sacrifices. We can extend this further and see these sailors as being the heroes whole tale because, while they started out following false gods, as soon as they were shown the truth, they turned and began to do things to please the true God.
That is the nature of the fear of the Lord I carried for the longest while as a Christ follower; I was afraid of God. Out of my being afraid of the Lord, I did many good things and sought to eradicate sin from my life. I tried to live up to the favor the Lord gave me. I tried to be good. Now, the motives were not wholly, or even mostly fear. But, there remained a residue of fear to the motives that lingered decades. The sailors were afraid of the Lord; I was afraid of the Lord.
Yet, I think Jonah had a far more correct apprehension of God than the sailors, or I, even in the midst of his seemingly suicidal disobedience. Jonah feared the Lord, and we can see later in the book how that played out, but his fear was of a different nature. He was not afraid of the Lord; he feared the Lord. He knew God and knew God’s nature far better than the sailors. He grew up immersed in all the stories of salvation of the Israelite people. God talked directly to Jonah. In the face of the immense power exhibited by God through the storm, Jonah was able to sleep because He knew God’s intent for Him. He knew God had no intent to harm him, but to use him. Jonah simply hated the use to which God intended for him.
Somehow, right in the very evidence of God’s wrath towards Jonah, he knew of God’s love for him. That is why he could sleep just as, centuries later, Jesus would sleep in a boat in the midst of a storm. Jonah was so secure in God’s love that he knew being thrown into a raging sea was no end of him. I suspect Jonah even knew all along that his running from God’s plan was ultimately futile, but he wanted to resist as long as possible.
The best analogy I have come to in my experience for what fear of the Lord is to me now comes from my time around horses. When I stand next to a horse or climb up on its back, I am keenly aware of the sheer size and power of the animal. That horse could crush me in a flash. It could kick me and shatter bones; rupture organs. That horse’s power is danger incarnate. Yet, I am also aware that the horse has no ill intent towards me (most of the time). Mostly, I am aware that the horse enjoys my presence, especially if I scratch behind its ears. My experience of these times is a paradox of high alert and peaceful rest.
My fear of the Lord is like that, except that God is no beast and his nature is not subject to the caprice of a horse. I am simultaneously aware that God could wipe me from existence in a mere moment and aware of His intense love for me. Not just love, but also, I am aware now of his eternal affection towards me. I am aware that He is pleased in me just as He is pleased in Christ, for I am in Christ. He may become displeased for me – that is, for the consequence of my sin that I still experience but, never again is He displeased IN me. God is with me through Christ and never flees or withdraws from me. Even in rebellious moment, He is with me. Wherever I go, even if I run from Him, there He is.
And so, I fear the Lord but, I no longer am afraid of the Lord. My motivation for doing good has also shifted as the fear has transformed. My motivation is borne now out of purer and purer love of God and love of others and fear of failing Him dissipates into mere moments occurring more infrequently. Grace abounds and God transforms. I, like Jonah, merely relinquish my own efforts to God who initiates, pursue, and perfects all that He has for me.
This doctrine of radical grace that I espouse is disturbing to many. Reactions abound: But what about sin – aren’t you being soft on sin? Aren’t you ignoring all the verses about God’s wrath? What about all the admonishments in the Bible to do good works? What about the whole book of James? Are you an Universalist – do you think God’s love just covers everything and we all get to heaven no matter what? I even had one person think I was being legalistic, though I am still dumbfounded by that one and can only conclude I said something very poorly.
Answers:
No, I am not an Universalist. I believe in free will and that we must receive Jesus to be saved. I just think we have no ability or power to cause this to happen. It all starts with Jesus and we can only come to Him when the Holy Spirit calls us. Those that refuse that call will not be saved in the last days.
As to the book of James, I believe it is primarily addressing walking out our horizontal relationship with others and secondarily addressing the barriers we experience towards God in that vertical relationship. James also is a big fan of infinite grace – consider James 4:6. I do not think James is about earning points with God at all, but if we read it with that mindset, it sure sounds like it. If we read it looking for grace, then we see it in abundance.
Good works are important and God calls us to them. However, doing them or not doing them does not impact the reality of the relationship with God that a Christ follower enters into. We just saw that with Jonah. Doing them or not doing either unleashes or impairs our love for others and our love back towards God, but God’s relationship with us is fixed and finished. Our experience of His relationship to us, well that is subject to our human frailty and failings.
God is both a God who exhibits wrath and exhibits love. However, His nature is Love. God is Love, as we are told in 1 John. For a non-believer, they are children of wrath (Eph 2:3-5) and under wrath. For believers, God’s wrath was exhausted upon Jesus (Isaiah 53:4) and we stand under His covering. Therefore, there is no wrath for us, but peace with God. We may experience wrath as a believer (remember experience is not reality), but I believe that is a misapprehension of God’s love. Jonah somehow saw the storm as God’s love and pursuit of him and not something intended to do him harm – so he could sleep in peace. Consider rubbing ones hand against the grain of rough-cut wood. It will be a bit painful and you will likely get splinters. Wrath, for a believer, is rubbing the wrong direction against God’s love.
Sin: Well, in my experience I was more tempted to sin and more likely to succumb to those temptations when I failed to comprehend God’s unending grace. This is because I remained a slave to fear, even if that fear was very slight or hidden, even a mere residue. There is no fear in love (1 John) but when fear exists, even in infinitesimal degrees, we are looking elsewhere than into the face of God’s love. That is when we are more susceptible to sin. Conversely, when we are awash in grace and absolutely certain of God’s favor and affection towards us, then our tendency to sin is at its lowest ebb. And, our desire to do good and exhibit God’s love to others and return love towards God is at its peak.
So, being an advocate for recognizing God’s rampant grace towards us does NOT mean I am soft on sin. On the contrary – I believe that salvation apart from grace requires absolutely perfect adherence to the law. It requires me to continuously love God with all my heart, mind and spirit. I cannot achieve that. Perhaps you can. I am rooting for you if you want to shoot for it, but only Jesus was successful. Sin, any sin, is death because God is entirely holy. Instead, I recognize that there is no degree of substantial compliance that I, or anyone, can achieve that will gain us admission into God’s Kingdom. I only gain admission by receiving grace.
Now that I am in that Kingdom, I am not left to “do my part”. Thank God, because I still cannot. Only the Holy Spirit working in me can transform my being, sanctify my life, and carry out my purpose. I am powerless to make any of that happen, and sometimes I chafe at not having some control so I begin trying again to sanctify myself. Sometimes I still want to run like Jonah. Doing my part is all and only that of surrendering. Surrendering does not mean passively sitting around (except sometimes it actually does mean that if so led). Rather, it means responding to the prompts of the Holy Spirit to do that which He directs and that which He empowers. A surrendered life ONLY comes from an apprehension of unbridled grace.